Nonprofit Toolbox

Janeal Ford, MPA, CFRE

With a career spanning two decades, I have worked with hundreds of grant making donors and prepared thousands of successful grant proposals. From the local service club wanting a one-page letter to the city government asking for a hundred-page response, every funder has unique and varying interests.

While all funders are unique, there are patterns in what grant makers are looking for, and over the years I have come to know the mistakes to avoid. As you look to prepare a competitive grant proposal for your noprofit, here are four things to do to avoid common mistakes before submitting your grant application.   

1. Follow Instructions 

Grant makers are fielding hundreds if not thousands of grant writing requests from charities. The volume of information means they too need systems to manage it.

Grant makers notice when applicants can’t/don’t follow instructions. They have spent time clarifying and defining when and how organizations can approach them, and your ability to follow these instructions influences their willingness to approve your grant.

If the guidelines convey they only want to fund food, don’t submit an unrelated request to cover salaries. Read the instructions once before you prepare the proposal, and again as a proofreading tool as you finalize it.   

2. Quit Playing Small

Grant makers may question applications when they read your organization claims to be the “only” one providing a particular service or program.

As a nonprofit, you may think this statement resoundingly asserts the rationale for your program. Unfortunately, the message often received is that you don’t have a command of other providers in the community or worse, you don’t play well with others.

Grant makers spend their time reading applications from organizations likely delivering services very similar to yours. The use of the word “only” may unintentionally invalidate your fellow colleagues who are working on the same issue, and may appear small-minded. Instead, share your value proposition and convey how your solution is unique or innovative within the ecosystem of providers in your area. 

3. Talk Solutions, Not Money

Nonprofit leaders eat, sleep and dream of more resources. There is no doubt you need resources to continue and expand your mission work.

While you are consumed with the need for money, presenting the unmet need as a need for money is a rookie move and grounds for immediate denial from a grant maker. As a credible nonprofit, a big part of your job is to confirm the unmet needs of the people you serve and educate grant makers on your solution.

Grant makers invest in solutions. Your organization’s job is to deploy them. Make the solution you offer the hero of the conversation, not the resources needed. Focus on the bigger community need and how your programs/services are inching closer to fully resolving or addressing the issue.    

4. Show What You Have, Not What You Don’t 

Grantmakers look closely at sustainability and generally want to avoid becoming an organization’s sole source of support.

This is why grant makers rarely support start-up nonprofits. They want to know you can keep your own lights on without their money and look to confirm that in a variety of ways.

Grant applications are full of questions designed to gather information on helping funders avoid supporting unsustainable organizations. It is common that once you secure support, a grant funder will continue to give to your organization each year because they view your solution as an investment. The logic follows finance and credit concepts. Those who need credit most have the biggest challenge securing it.

To garner support, your charity needs to demonstrate its ability to garner resources from other places. Success begets success. Leverage the assets, partnerships, results, and support you already have. This can include committed volunteers, engaged board members, donated goods or professional services, shared facilities, community partnerships, and other in-kind contributions that strengthen your work.

Strengthen Your Next Grant Application

Grant makers are allies in helping you move your mission forward and give for a variety of reasons. Honor this by taking the time to listen and understand where they are coming from. Read more tips on how to engage with funders here.  

Need help with grant writing? IN Fundraising can help. Schedule a free consultation now.

Editor’s note: An earlier version of this article was published in Youth Today’s Nonprofit Toolbox. It was updated in October 2026 for clarity and to reflect IN Fundraising’s current branding and resources.